GOLDEN Bachelor star Gerry Turner has been brutally overshadowed by ex-girlfriends Susan Noles and Kathy Swarts following his split from Theresa Nist.
The Indiana native, 71, and his ex, 70, announced their split on April 12 after tying the knot in January in a television special.
During Tuesday’s episode of Single Happy Hour: Golden Hour podcast, hosted by Gerry’s ex-girlfriends Kathy, 71, and Susan, 67, covered the split between Gerry and his ex-wife Theresa, 70.
Kathy and Susan made their stance clear, supporting Theresa in the divorce.
Although Susan stated on the show that she needed to defend Gerry “a little bit” in the conversation, noting that Theresa refused to move or give up her job, she and Kathy ended up supporting their fellow Golden Bachelor contestant.
“He was frustrated, who could blame him? I would never have said I would move to that place. He lives in the middle of nowhere,” Susan said.
Kathy laughed a little at the ordeal, but stood firm by her friend’s side.
“Gerry made a big — let me emphasize a big — mistake. He could have stayed with Susan. He could have gotten me,” she said with a laugh before adding, “Okay, not really.”
She then added: “Gerry is a great guy. Theresa is a lovely lady, you know, it happens. Sorry, it happens.”
“We like them both, but you know, I’m sorry, you know someone for a month or six weeks and these things happen.”
Susan agreed, noting that their love was definitely “real.”
UNDER FIRE
Gerry has suffered a lot since the split, with many flippers on Theresa’s side.
The backlash got to the point where the reality star’s daughter, Angie, had to step in and plead with critics.
Angie addressed hate towards his father in an Instagram post, begging fans to back off.
She shared a photo of a message that read, “Everything always works out in the end,” along with a long post she wrote.
The Golden Bachelor contestants
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e4637/e4637dd0ff8ed34e473da42bb294839d05278934" alt=""
In 2023, the world met its first Golden Bachelor, Gerry Turner.
Meet all the women competing for Gerry’s heart.
- Theresa Nist (WINNER)
- Leslie Fhima (runner-up)
- Martin Faith
- Ellen Goltzer
- Sandra Mason
- Susan Noles
- April Kirkwood
- Kathy Swarts
- Nancy Hulkower
- Cristina Kempton
- Edith Aguirre
- Joan Vassos (FIRST GOLDEN BACHELORETTE)
- Jeanie Howard
- Natasha Hardee
- Peggy Dercole
- Marina Pereira
- Anna Zalk
- Maria Trice
- Pamela Burns
- patty james
- Renée Halverson-Wright
- Sílvia Robledo
Theresa and Gerry were married in January live on ABC. Four months later, the two announced that they were divorcing.
“It’s no surprise that the news of my father and Theresa’s decision to separate has stirred up a range of emotions and opinions. I love how invested people are in the program, what an experience to have you along for the ride!
“What has been disheartening is the level of anger and cruelty our family has faced. My dad and Theresa are kind, good people who made this decision for them, no one else. , there are real people with real feelings.”
Gerry’s daughter continued: “To all those who chose to show love and compassion to my father, Theresa and our family… Thank you from the bottom of my heart.”
She also praised Andy Levine, co-host of the dating advice podcast Dear Shandy, who also defended the former Golden Bachelor couple in an episode.
BACHING
Gerry and Theresa announced their decision to separate on Good Morning America.
The reality star couple revealed they couldn’t agree on their living situation.
Gerry lives in Indiana, while Theresa lives in New Jersey.
For this reason, they decided to end their marriage.
Fans were stunned by the news after watching the wedding on television in January.
Many encouraged them to consider televising their divorce, mocking them for thinking the relationship would work.
“Will the divorce proceedings also be televised?” one fan joked in an online thread.
“What a shocking and unexpected turn of events,” another person commented.
“Oh no, who could have predicted that?” a third person joked.
After news of the divorce broke, Golden Bachelor contestant April Kirkwood, 66, claimed she warned Theresa about Gerry.
“I really tried to tell you, but this was your lesson to live by. Much love!” April wrote in the Instagram comments about Theresa’s post thanking her fans for their kindness following the news.
Gerry’s father Everett, 92, also revealed he didn’t fully agree to the marriage.
“I couldn’t say why [but] Right off the bat, Theresa pissed me off,” he told The US Sun exclusively.
Gerry and Theresa got engaged during the November 30 season finale of Golden Bachelor.
Gerry was adamant during his GMA appearance announcing his divorce that he still had feelings for Theresa.
“I still love this person,” he said. “I have no doubt that I am still in love with her.”
Theresa shared a similar sentiment and the couple held hands during the interview.
This story originally appeared on The-sun.com read the full story