Collective amnesia seems to have reached the conservative majority in the Supreme Courtespecially around the question: is the president above the law?
Five of the six conservative justices who decided to give the president absolute immunity from “fundamental” presidential duties appear to have made contradictory statements during their Senate confirmation hearings.
“No man is above the law”, Neil Gorsuch told Senator Patrick Leahy (D-VT) during your confirmation hearing in 2017.
Gorsuch even doubled down, calling the court’s landmark 1952 ruling a Youngstown vs. Sawyer, who reigned in presidential authority, a “brilliant opinion.”
Similarly, Brett Kavanaugh told the Senate that “no one is above the law” during his 2018 confirmation hearing, according to CNN. Amy Coney Barrett agreed during his hearing, but like Kavanaugh, overshadowed in presidential pardons, according to The New York Times.
“That question may or may not arise, but it requires a legal analysis of what the scope of the pardon power is,” Barrett told the Senate about extending the presidential pardon.
Kavanaugh told the Senate: “The issue of self-pardon is something I have never looked at.”
In Samuel Alito confirmation hearing he told the Senate that “no president, Democrat or Republican, no president is above the law, just like you, not me, not anyone in this room.”
Alito also praised the Youngstown decision, adding that during Watergate it was “the responsibility of the judiciary to stand firm” by forcing President Nixon to comply with subpoenas.
Chief Justice John Roberts agreedquoting Youngstown as binding the president to the law.
“Senator, I believe that no one is above the law in our system, and that includes the president,” he said at his confirmation hearing in 2005. “The president is completely subject to the law, the Constitution and the statutes. Now, issues often arise where there is a conflict between the Legislature and the Executive over the exercise of executive authority, the executive authority said. The framework for analyzing this is in Youngstown Sheet and Tube case, the famous case resulting from President Truman’s seizure of the steel mills.
Presidential pardons, Youngstown and presidential immunity were not discussed in Clarence Thomas confirmation hearing.
Read more at The Daily Beast.
Get the Daily Beast’s biggest news and scandals delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe now.
Stay informed and get unlimited access to the Daily Beast’s unmatched reporting. Subscribe now.
Five SCOTUS Justices’ Comments on Prez Immunity Come Back to Haunt Them
Collective amnesia seems to have reached the conservative majority in the Supreme Courtespecially around the question: is the president above the law?
Five of the six conservative justices who decided to give the president absolute immunity from “fundamental” presidential duties appear to have made contradictory statements during their Senate confirmation hearings.
“No man is above the law”, Neil Gorsuch told Senator Patrick Leahy (D-VT) during your confirmation hearing in 2017.
Gorsuch even doubled down, calling the court’s landmark 1952 ruling a Youngstown vs. Sawyer, who reigned in presidential authority, a “brilliant opinion.”
Similarly, Brett Kavanaugh told the Senate that “no one is above the law” during his 2018 confirmation hearing, according to CNN. Amy Coney Barrett agreed during his hearing, but like Kavanaugh, overshadowed in presidential pardons, according to The New York Times.
“That question may or may not arise, but it requires a legal analysis of what the scope of the pardon power is,” Barrett told the Senate about extending the presidential pardon.
Kavanaugh told the Senate: “The issue of self-pardon is something I have never looked at.”
In Samuel Alito confirmation hearing he told the Senate that “no president, Democrat or Republican, no president is above the law, just like you, not me, not anyone in this room.”
Alito also praised the Youngstown decision, adding that during Watergate it was “the responsibility of the judiciary to stand firm” by forcing President Nixon to comply with subpoenas.
Chief Justice John Roberts agreedquoting Youngstown as binding the president to the law.
“Senator, I believe that no one is above the law in our system, and that includes the president,” he said at his confirmation hearing in 2005. “The president is completely subject to the law, the Constitution and the statutes. Now, issues often arise where there is a conflict between the Legislature and the Executive over the exercise of executive authority, the executive authority said. The framework for analyzing this is in Youngstown Sheet and Tube case, the famous case resulting from President Truman’s seizure of the steel mills.
Presidential pardons, Youngstown and presidential immunity were not discussed in Clarence Thomas confirmation hearing.
Read more at The Daily Beast.
Get the Daily Beast’s biggest news and scandals delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe now.
Stay informed and get unlimited access to the Daily Beast’s unmatched reporting. Subscribe now.
Source link
Support fearless, independent journalism
We are not owned by a billionaire or shareholders – our readers support us. Donate any amount over $2. BNC Global Media Group is a global news organization that delivers fearless investigative journalism to discerning readers like you! Help us to continue publishing daily.
Support us just once
We accept support of any size, at any time – you name it for $2 or more.
Trump was hit with a harsh dose of reality after blatantly trying to rewrite history
Madhvi Chittoor: TIME’s child of the year list
Former Willard High coach to stand trial on student sex charges four years after arrest
South Lebanon Twp. Police are looking for clues after several vehicle break-ins and thefts
Related
Trump was hit with a harsh dose of reality after blatantly trying to rewrite history
Former Willard High coach to stand trial on student sex charges four years after arrest
South Lebanon Twp. Police are looking for clues after several vehicle break-ins and thefts
Lexington restaurant evicted from National Avenue after fatal mass shooting
The Two Worst Mistakes Investors Can Make Right Now
More
UAW hits Trump and Musk with federal labor charges over anti-union comments
Bluesky: Social media site reports surge in new UK users following Elon Musk’s riot comments | Science and technology news
‘I was crushed, the comments were insane,’ says mother of three as she is trolled for Christmas food hack to save money
I’m a mum and I get nasty comments about my body – I was told I should be ‘half my size’, now the trolls have another complaint
Jack Smith seeks more time to plan after immunity ruling
Russia’s Deripaska criticized for rare anti-war comments
Zach Bryan’s fans demand girlfriend Brianna Chickenfry ‘apologize’ as racist comments resurface
NFL fans feel the ‘Cowboys’ slump’ after CeeDee Lamb and Micah Parsons’ reaction to Jerry Jones’ ‘urgency’ comments
Jamaican singer Spice reveals how she went from church choir to making NSFW hits – and the sexist comments she still receives
Trolls flocked to the comments of my dance video to call me a ‘whale’ – they say I’ll die at 30 but earn £15k a MONTH
Germany and France criticize Israeli minister’s comments on hunger in Gaza
Judge in Trump silence case postpones date for ruling on presidential immunity
‘Is this Britain or the Soviet Union?’: Elon Musk hits back after video appears to show man arrested for Facebook comments | Politics News
PM warns anyone inciting online violence to face full force of law after Elon Musk’s ‘civil war’ comments | Politics News
Crockett condemns Trump’s racial comments: Imagine what he says ‘about the rest of us’
Pompeo says Harris’ comments on Israel-Hamas war are ‘fueling’ conflict
Geraldo Rivera calls Trump’s comments about Harris ‘insulting’
Taylor Rooks surprises fans and steals the show on the red carpet as Joy Taylor and Kaylee Hartung leave adoring comments
Trump’s comments on Harris’ race cast clouds on his campaign
New fallout over Trump’s comments about Harris’ racial identity
‘Tom Brady is the GOAT’ Lamar Jackson insists after coach John Harbaugh’s comments about his high expectations for the QB
Hogan Slams Trump Over NABJ’s Racial Comments: ‘The American People Deserve Better’
The Latest: Trump on defense after race comments and Vance’s rough pitch
Schumer Introduces No Kings Act Against Presidential Immunity
In Attempt to Overturn Supreme Court Immunity Ruling, Schumer Introduces No Kings Act
In Attempt to Overturn Supreme Court Immunity Ruling, Schumer Introduces No Kings Act
Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer Tries to Remove Presidential Immunity
YouTube star MrBeast acknowledges ‘inappropriate’ comments | US News
Kelly says Trump’s NABJ comments are from a ‘desperate old man’ and ‘scared old man’
Kelly says Trump’s NABJ comments are from a ‘desperate old man’ and ‘scared old man’
The latest: Trump will hold a press conference; Harris to speak about Medicare drug price cuts
Latest updates from NHC on Category 1 Hurricane Ernesto
Eva Longoria, 49, Loves This L’Oreal Root Spray — Down to $10 on Amazon
Greenland court extends detention of whaling activist Watson
Fantasy Football Rankings: 6 Players Who Should Have Higher Grades This Draft Season